Random stuff from my life and mind.
Wednesday, August 27, 2008

 I have a huge problem with the banning of any book, recently the iPhone application Comic Reader has been rejected because it can read the Murderdrome http://www.infuriouscomics.com/ comic series. I’m guessing you can assume from the title it’s not a fluffy happy kid’s comic. But this is a comic book. A work of drawing and word balloons. It is imaginary. It is fiction.

The application Comic Reader was submitted to the Apple App Store and the publishers received notice that it was being rejected for violating terms of the Software Developer Kit which states:

“Applications must not contain any obscene, pornographic, offensive or defamatory content or materials of any kind (text, graphics, images, photographs, etc.), or other content or materials that in Apple’s reasonable judgment may be found objectionable by iPhone or iPod touch users.”

Hold up a minute…. They are banning content not the application, the application can be used for many, many, different comics.  Apple sells Reservoir Dogs http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reservoir_Dogs in their iTunes store, arguably one of the most violent and graphic movies ever made, and apple sells the unrated version.

                The Soviet Union banned the The Bible and The Quran from libraries during 1926 to 1956. Who does Apple think they are

 

5 Comments:
Anonymous Anonymous said...
Apple is not a country, they can choose to sell or not sell anything they want. That is not BANNING, it is business. Now if the government did it you would have a point but again Apple is not the government.

Anonymous Anonymous said...
It is both business and censoring. If their principle is to avoid distributing offensive content, they haven't lived up to it as they are banning an application not the material it shows!

Plus, as the blog points out, they are distributing offensive content in other cases... they are being foolishly inconsistent.

So, it's a poor business practice, too... someone there isn't minding the store (or maybe it's that they're minding it improperly! :-)

Anonymous Anonymous said...
A business can censor (sic) what they want. One might make a case for poor business practice but it is in Apple's right on how to run their business, which includes what they choose to sell and not sell. If one doesn't like it then do the capitalist thing and buy the product elsewhere.

Blogger PK said...
You don't like it don't use it...

Anonymous Anonymous said...
I'd love to use the other application store that the iPhone works with, oh yeah nevermind....

Links to this post:
Create a Link